3 Greatest Irish Footballers

[thehighwayman]

When I saw the headline before I read this post I thought the same as Westcorklad.

1. Brady
2. Keane
3. McGrath

[MR JOLLY]

When I saw the headline before I read this post I thought the same as Westcorklad.

1. Brady
2. Keane
3. McGrath

Ditto.... unless best is allowed

[loneranger2]

Brady, Giles and Mc Grath.
No place for that whining overrated deserter (remember Saipan) thug (remember Inge Halland challenge) managerial failure Keane !!!!!

[ninebythree]

Brady, Giles and Mc Grath.
No place for that whining overrated deserter (remember Saipan) thug (remember Inge Halland challenge) managerial failure Keane !!!!!

as this is westcorklad thread.........i just remind you of three things and say no more........


Brady ....fucked celtic when he was manager there.
The record shows that mick mccarthy sent keane home from saipan, a world cup that he dragged them kicking and screaming to.
And as for managerial failure , where were sunderland when keane took over and they won the championship.

nbt

[kieree]

1. McShane
2. Kilbane
3. Babb

[westcorklad]

1. McShane
2. Kilbane
3. Babb

Whoever floats your boat I suppose

[WWLhad]

Best
Keane
Brady

[loneranger2]

It's all about personal opinion and I agree with Nbt that Brady did a dreadful job at Celtic BUT I honestly believe Keane acquired 'martyr' status after Saipan. I am not a fan of McCarthy or his "row Z" but think of the games Keane ducked pre Saipan.
Giles was the best all round I reckon. Super skill and hard as nails.

LR2.

[Alec Horan]

Johnny, Liam, Paul.

with a special mention for Ray and Shay Given.

Nice to see so many votes for ROI all time top scorer, Robbie.: )

[villager]

Brady ....fucked celtic when he was manager there.

And as for managerial failure , where were sunderland when keane took over and they won the championship.

nbt

I thought the question was about best footballer not manager.

my three:
1.brady
2. mcgrath
3. keane.(i hate the man but cannot deny he was a great player)