Yes, let everyman judge for himself and tastes differ but no matter what differences there are,each guy has to make his own call and I think asking him to say ' fairly' with no other alternative is unfair and can be insulting where the reviewer doesnt want to insult , recognises that she is attractive but yet feels in his eyes she just falls short of top marks.
I think it is right that the reviewer be asked to specifically comment on this as it is important and he may have ommitted to address it in his main comments. photos can not be representative of the girl, good or bad, and I really appreciate hearing a view ' from the horses mouth '.!