I was curious as to what makes a great review (apart from the girl that is)

Is is the grammar, layout, story, authentic, "impartial", critical....

It would be great if people would give their opinion and example of what they think is a good review/reviewer

Leaving aside those that write lots of reviews,

What reviews would you regard as a great review.. Apart from OMG, amazing.... Treat her nice....

Do people just write reviews a free advertising for the person being reviewed or something to share with the reader

Do reviews share the moment, make you excited to visits the person being reviewed...

Curious to get both sides and also what kind of reviews make the person being reviewed cringe...

Would be great to get everyone's view (do mods have a view, what is and is not an acceptable review)

I also wonder if you think a "bad review" is still a good review...

I love the fact that EI is such an active forum and look forward to getting as broad a perspective as possible