sex work akin to selling organs

[saoirsemac]

was having a discussion with someone who thinks we should criminalising the clients, to stamp out prositition

which to this person sex work is rape usual old scéal


the person arguement when i suggested criminalising sex work hasnt worked, doesnt work and puts women in danger

i explain my reasoning, and the reply was who cares if the few who choose it get a hard time tough, its about stopping it

allowing it, is the same as allowing u to sell your organs


is it the same?

the person saw sex work harmful to its victim, the provider and sees it in the same terms as selling an organ,


i argued the war on drugs that making something illegal does not make it go away


weirdly this person is rather alternative and an occaisonal users of illegal drugs and watches porn

which i argued there paid to have sex, buts its ok because both are... and there actors, now i know the industrys differ of course

but people are forced in porn, think child porn for one example


no industry is ever free form abuse, but porn been regulated is prob the least amount,

and human organs well are for sale on the blackmarket and its not willing people selling them either

so what if we allowed people to sell legally nd above board organs in safe envoirments,


should we idealistic and believe we can stop these markets? if u do where do we stop? will we seek stamp out tobacco next, drink, sex outside marraige? peoples verisons of uthopia differ after all,

or should we be realistic and say it will happen, accept it and try regulate it to make it as safe as possaible


ireland copped on sex happen outside marraige and gay sex, so eventually we needed to sort out the issue of contraceptive, and make it available to all and make sex safer, be it hetro homo married or one night stand

the idealistic wud have stayed true to the idea, you should have sex when married with someone u love to make babies, if we stuck to trying to drum that into people so they might stop, wudnt we be a sorry mess now eh?



so in conculsion what i am asking is if you allow a sex industry, the longest working one in know history, is it really the same as allowing organs for sale?

the risk to life in organ sales, been slightly higher than a blowjob

[dob]

Where do these nutty ideas come from?

How do argue with people with such views?

Totally illogical attitude.

[JMastodon]

How did you remain sane, Saoirse, debating with that person? I would not have been able to keep my cool.

[cheryl20]

That's just ridiculous...that person is comparing pleasure with selling organs??Did he ever go to escort?I'm sure he would change his opinion quickly....

[ber]

Its only the same if u sell ure Kidney so that u can pay to see an escort.
PS tell the escort to be careful of ure stitches

[saoirsemac]

in civi life this is gritted teeth for me, esp when im told im clueless etc

kinda like my mum saying thats shocking the sex parties for children in athlone

because the paper told her, it a results party called fuck results, as in fuck it no matter wat u do tonights for u

[gaze]

Saoise, Reason is something that these people can not deal with. We have seen it in the abortion referendum, and if you work out the number of hours spent debating that issue by our Government, it would make you wonder. Are there no other problems that the government have?
If politicians have to vote on new laws, how will they explain to their partners as to the way they voted.....There will be so much hypocrisy

[Ray]

People who don't agree with something need to compare it to something else, the comparison in this case is FUCKING STUPID, in general I have no problem with people having there own opinions as long as they can state why, does not have to be logical to me, but don't compare it to something with no real comparisons,

FUCK OFF EVERY ONE

[Sensual Lauren]

this entire line of thought is ridiculous..,

[saoirsemac]

this entire line of thought is ridiculous..,

The person believes both are as dangerous as we risk violence and rape (ive had more black eyes sprained fingers working in a health care)

This person sees these risk the same as selling ur organs where in ireland one in five surgeries result in infections nd in some hosiptals 1 in 6 have mrsa

Another note on health very few die of cancer they die of medical complications etc