Should this review be ratted?

[El Gordo]

Because I just noticed it was ratted a couple of weeks ago. It wasn't ratted when I read it before. I didn't pay attention to the date. I think a reason should be given for ratted reviews, don't you?

It hasn't just been ratted. It has been ratted since at least January. You are imagining things.

[debest]

It hasn't just been ratted. It has been ratted since at least January. You are imagining things.

Where did I say it has just been ratted? You are imagining things.

[El Gordo]

There are lots of reviews ratted with no reason given. You've picked one that was ratted ages ago, a review of two ladies who no longer tour Ireland. Why? What are you up to?

[debest]

There are lots of reviews ratted with no reason given. You've picked one that was ratted ages ago, a review of two ladies who no longer tour Ireland. Why? What are you up to?

WTF?? What are you up to here? What do you think I'm up to?

Like I've said, I trust this guys reviews from personal experiance and don't think his review should be ratted. I don't recall noticing any of these other reviews.

You're taking back what you said about me imagining things then? Apology accepted.

[debest]

Fuck that bastard needs castrated
unfortunatly were meeting more and more men every day with the same attitude

So you think his review should be ratted because he's a bastard? Or is castration enough?

[debest]

did I miss read that review or was he on about bare back sex

The editing of the review is confusing. I read it before it was edited. He was on about OWO.

[debest]

Don't think his review should be ratted on content but maybe it's ratted for other reasons which the review mods like to kept to them selves as to not let everyone know how to escape an review from being ratted

but he does need his balls placed between two bricks, there's no need for his in this day and age to have such a nasty attitude towards escorts

I see what you're saying and I agree he comes across as an ignorant twat. But he has a right to his opinion.

[debest]

Opinions are split so far. Anon (as usual) is the only one to give me a genuine reason why the review is ratted.

ElGordo, when you figure out my agenda make sure you post it. I'm sure everyone wants to know, including myself.

[El Gordo]

Since some of the people voting haven't been around long enough to know the full story, let me explain the context here.

Busty Malena and Carmen had a big public fight on the boards with Liz Hilton, who was later banned for various offences, including posting people's personal information on her blog. This fight, which had been going on for a while, got really nasty in late January of 2009.

On the afternoon of 19 January 2009 three things happened at roughly the same time:
- dingdong visited Liz and wrote a glowing review,
- he suddenly "remembered" that he had visited BM&C the previous year and wrote a negative review, their only negative review, and
- An Garda Siochana raided BM&C's hotel room, acting on an anonymous tip.

Shortly after this, BM&C's tour ended. They have never come back.

Now I don't know dingdong, and it is theoretically possible that this is all coincidence and that his negative review of BM&C had nothing to do with his visit to Liz, or to her fight with them. But the timing certainly doesn't look good.

And I don't know you, debest, so I don't know why you are suddenly trying to get this rat removed, more than a year and a half after all this happened.

[debest]

Since some of the people voting haven't been around long enough to know the full story, let me explain the context here.

Busty Malena and Carmen had a big public fight on the boards with Liz Hilton, who was later banned for various offences, including posting people's personal information on her blog. This fight, which had been going on for a while, got really nasty in late January of 2009.

On the afternoon of 19 January 2009 three things happened at roughly the same time:
- dingdong visited Liz and wrote a glowing review,
- he suddenly "remembered" that he had visited BM&C the previous year and wrote a negative review, their only negative review, and
- An Garda Siochana raided BM&C's hotel room, acting on an anonymous tip.

Shortly after this, BM&C's tour ended. They have never come back.

Now I don't know dingdong, and it is theoretically possible that this is all coincidence and that his negative review of BM&C had nothing to do with his visit to Liz, or to her fight with them. But the timing certainly doesn't look good.

And I don't know you, debest, so I don't know why you are suddenly trying to get this rat removed, more than a year and a half after all this happened.

Why didn't you just say all this in the first place?

I've only started posting here in the last few months and had no idea about any of this. I never asked for it to be unratted, just looking for others opinions on why they thought it was ratted.

I've already stated that me and dingdong have seen some of the same escorts and he was bang on in his reviews. I read this review some time last year, it's certainly a memorable review and I didn't forget it. Before I started this thread https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...-profiles.html, I noticed that the same review had been ratted and I couldn't understand why. I initially thought it was because of the language he used, but he uses this type of langauge in most of his reviews. Now you have provided this info (which I thank you for), I'll approach his reviews with caution.

If this is how it all went down, then I agree that a coincidence is unlikely and it deserves a rat.