In reality, does no other user (and reviewer) think that this is a little off? This reviewer saw this escort with his wife and then on his own. Surely those would be very different experiences, as different as seeing an escort alone or as a duo... It must be something that would be accepted as an exception to the general rule (which I agree with completely)....
Even if the two reviews arent kept current, I think that the reviewer should have two reviews rather than one...
I have been disagreed with already by some very respected members of the site as well as the moderator who had to make a call on what to do with the two reviews.... If I have any support, I would love to see it as postings because that is the only thing thatg will make a difference. If not, then I am in danger of being considered to be part of the lunatic fringe!!!
BLD
Maybe you mis-interpreted me, I totally agree with you comment, in this instance he should really be allowed a second review as they were 2 completely different experiences but QPH's point and I agree with him, the rules are quite clear, 1 positive or 1 negative review or 1 of both per member.
Qph
Is it not the case that you are going on your interpretation of the rules? My view is that the two should be allowed (albeit on the basis of an intelligent interpretation of the rules)
Before you respond, I am not saying that you are not intelligent.... I just think that one could have interpreted the rules differently... But then, I would say that, wouldn't I....
BLD
Read the rules, there is no ambiguity contained in them, there is zero room for interpretation, its ONE review per poster and until it says that if you bring the football team along with you and that allows you to write 11 reviews not including the subs then that is what is going to continue to be done.
One review per reviewer and older one deleted.
Last edited by Quarterpoundher; 04-08-10 at 01:43.
Oh FFS, why don't you just pm the guy and ask him to get his wife to register here and leave a review for her too...........
Problem solved..............................
"It's far easier to fight for principles than to live up to them."
L
An don (04-08-10)
But his original point is the guy left 2 reviews, even if the second review is removed which is what he is against the review count or the reviewers' profile should still say 2 because he is not a one time reviewer and he would be taken more seriously by him and others..
BTW, Why is bigladdub ignoring all my posts and only picking the ones he feels he can get confrontational on and get a dig in at QPH, I'm not feeling the love from this guy
If the total review tally showed when older review was deleted then that would screw up the review leader board as some people review same escort 3, 4 sometimes 5 times. If people glance and see 1 review logged and do not read the review and not see it said that its his second review and dismiss them as a 1 review wonder there is not a lot we can do about that. The one review system was set up to address a separate issue and this is one side effect of that. People should perhaps not dismiss people with one review until they read the review, its only an extra click after all.
Surly ye are not all so knackered from riding you can't muster the strength for one more click?