MeathVLouth : U watchin?

[anon361]

you said earlier you did not watch it...how do you know all this?

Boardroom chit chat, I'm not qualified to make a decsion myself, just learning from you guys and listening to what I am being told, doesn't efect me really either way, I would always be in favour of the fair outcome even if that ment Louth being awarded the game but I would still like to be sure it was the fair decision..

Taking ALL factors into account and not just the last one..

[ber]

But when you start analysing a game and saying one decision was wrong it is equally as wrong to exclude all the other bad decisions that did effect the score within the SAME game..

U have decisions that are game defining same as u have decisions that are life defining, u cant compare decisions made during
a game to a decision made on the stroke of full time which allowed no time to recover. If for argument sake it happened in the first half it would have a totally different bearing on the game

[anon361]

U have decisions that are game defining same as u have decisions that are life defining, u cant compare decisions made during
a game to a decision made on the stroke of full time which allowed no time to recover. If for argument sake it happened in the first half it would have a totally different bearing on the game

But thats the bit I don't understand, why should it be the only factor, surely a bad decision mid way is the same as a bad decision at the end, so if your going to overturn the refs last bad decision and give louth the win surely you should also overturn his other 3 decisions that gave louth points and give it back to meath again..

[ber]

But thats the bit I don't understand, why should it be the only factor, surely a bad decision mid way is the same as a bad decision at the end, so if your going to overturn the refs last bad decision and give louth the win surely you should also overturn his other 3 decisions that gave louth points and give it back to meath again..

No i played enough of this game to know the twists and turns a game can take, for instance a bad decision against a team if they have time to recover often spurs them on to greater effort and can be a negative for the team that got the decision, there is a saying in the game that goals win games and often decisions regarding goals have a huge bearing on a game because they are a major score .So muh of the game is about mental strenght aswell as ability and the pattern of a game can dictate how players respond.