Trusted Reviewer Criteria Reaction

[cavanman]

This criteria is way to complicated, in order for a fair review system to work it needs to be simple.

Can you imagine asking an escort does she do OWO, Role Play and can you give me a reference for the EI forum , will she also charge for the time taken to write it.

Trusted reviewers come with experience so anyone with just one view as opposed to someone with 20 or 30 certaintly carries more weight with me. Maybe allow only members who contribute to the boards to review or who have a certain number of contributions ie 10+.

[punterminator]

Which part in particular do you think is causing the most problems???

The three written references. I mean, It's pretty obvious that my reviews are on the level but there is absolutely no way I'm going to the trouble of getting three references just for a badge.

Also, this idea of mods sitting down cogitating over my credentials is kinda laughable..

[thehighwayman]

The escorts have no problems writing the requested references. I don't see what the problem with all this. What's wrong with them verifying that they saw you?

[punterminator]

The escorts have no problems writing the requested references. I don't see what the problem with all this. What's wrong with them verifying that they saw you?

I'm sure they don't - what makes you think that the punters will be inclined to do this though? I know I certainly won't be doing it.

[thehighwayman]

No you won't be doing it because you have a badge already.

[punterminator]

No you won't be doing it because you have a badge already.

I thought they were all being rescinded?

[thehighwayman]

No it's new ones were looking for to add to the existing holders.

[punterminator]

No it's new ones were looking for to add to the existing holders.

Ah right...
Still think it's ridiculous though..

[Last time]

I wonder at this stage are the mods thinking 'maybe this wasn't such a clever idea?' Shouldn't take too much brain power to work it out....

When I am looking at an escorts reviews I look to see how many reviews the punter has made. I generally start with those who have the most. Then I look at their previous reviews to see if we have similar tastes or been with the same escorts to judge if they are real or trustworthy.

The badge thing has now made me look at those with badges and think 'now there is a sad git who applied for a badge by asking girls to review him' (although he may have had one before). As said before most girls have problems giving you directions let alone understanding this idiotic bureaucy.

I know from reviews and PM's that other punters have followed my reviews, as I have other, as we have similar tastes. This is not because I/someone has or hasn't got a badge.

I think back to the drawing board lads...

[punterminator]

I wonder at this stage are the mods thinking 'maybe this wasn't such a clever idea?' Shouldn't take too much brain power to work it out....

Well, judging by the fact that they came up with this comedy show between them, I'm guessing that brains are not in plentiful supply in that particular group..

Though in fairness, sad gits who apply to be reviewers are probably the same sad gits who get their cheapies mod'ing a web forum.