This criteria is way to complicated, in order for a fair review system to work it needs to be simple.
Can you imagine asking an escort does she do OWO, Role Play and can you give me a reference for the EI forum , will she also charge for the time taken to write it.
Trusted reviewers come with experience so anyone with just one view as opposed to someone with 20 or 30 certaintly carries more weight with me. Maybe allow only members who contribute to the boards to review or who have a certain number of contributions ie 10+.