Look at the activity reports on those two false negative reviews, they haven't been active since reviewing, dont contribute etc etc. Does that not spell out hit and run and a sniper attack. They just joined purely to slander and make a bad review. I have accepted the one bad review that i received from goodman in Cork as i did meet that man. We obviously just didn't get on, but that is to be expected i cant get on with everyone.
With regards to the scheme, sounds great but this doesn't eliminate the one review hit wonders. Even though they aren't credited reviewers.
Each reviewer should be active on the site, contribute to the site, log on every so often.
How easy is it to create a fake email, and fake membership on ei.....
The mods should contact such member when a review is clearly a target and clearly fake one, or if a lady wants to confirm the actual meeting even took place and send a confirmation email or something along those lines, how about sending them a pm and seeing if you get a response??