I would be interested in this thing: if Garda stop u as a client asking like the lady asked this guy:'' may i talk with u? ' u have the right to refuse to talk and just answer plain , no i dont want to talk? on what basis they can detain you? or can they? If they cant detain you then u free to go, right?
Last edited by FetishCherry; 30-01-19 at 15:28.
Established Member
Becoming Addicted to E-I
If are you stopped by the Guards like this guy was, if in public place and asked for your name and address, give it to them, you could be detained or arrested otherwise and why would you not give it to them.
Then just be nice and act normal.
Remember they are the law and this guy was getting into his vehicle too, being a smart alec here and they could ask for drivers license MOT Test cert, check tyres, brake lights and look over your entire car so don't bring them on you like this
I have been stopped a few times and found if you're civil and cooperative then they are okay and you'll be on your way in no time.
Don't worry so much
bmw528 (30-01-19),FetishCherry (30-01-19)
The only way Garda can prevent you leaving a location after you have indicated your wish to leave (legally) is to arrest you. If they try to keep you in a location after you have told them you wish to leave, they themselves could be committing an offence.Originally Posted by FetishCherry
bmw528 (30-01-19),
Isn't that what this poor guy was & look where it got him! civil & cooperative but don't incriminate yourself, you were stopped a few times? leaving an escorts place?
bmw528 (30-01-19),
glad to hear this
bmw528 (30-01-19)
Established Member
Becoming Addicted to E-I
No, if you are uncooperative the Guards can legally detain you, it is different to arresting you so be aware of this too
bmw528 (30-01-19)
conflicting opinions here, exactly why EI should pony up & get us proper legal advice, it's in their interest to keep the punters flowing
Their is no such thing in the civilized western world as "legally detained" outside being arrested. Although I suspect some Garda would try to bullshit you otherwise. "Legally detained" is arrested.
bmw528 (30-01-19),
Established Member
Becoming Addicted to E-I
you can be both civil & cooperative without giving yourself up
bmw528 (30-01-19),
Established Member
Becoming Addicted to E-I
its not they are different, you can be detained without being arrested.
Why are people worrying so much about this anyway, All you have to give is you name address and that's it.
People here putting the frighteners on one another for no reason.
bmw528 (30-01-19)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote