Pink Floyd x

**wolfie** · 01-03-13, 12:15

**thewren** · 01-03-13, 12:15

Ah.. brings back memories ! I prefer to see them 'mature' , in concert..

Been missing you btw

xx[/QUOTE]

Ya You too

**Stephanie** · 01-03-13, 12:25

And of course :

**Stephanie** · 01-03-13, 12:30

Originally Posted by wolfie

The Wall [/video]

I wanted to post the Film version, but it has kids in it. Brill Film

xx

**Clyde** · 01-03-13, 15:55

Ah yes the wall a music revolution in its day and bob Geldof playing the lead role in the movie ... Classic

**mellors** · 01-03-13, 17:16

Originally Posted by Martin Mod

Pink Floyd after Roger Waters left seem more of a tribute band. Gilmour could never written anything of the genius of Waters

A little harsh, as with many bands its a combination of talents

Originally Posted by Stephanie

This song just makes me cry when i hear it.

Saw them on the Pulse tour where they did the whole of Dark Side...brilliant

Talkinng about a combination of talents, could it ever be the same without Rick Wright whose sadly no longer with us ?

**johnnybbad** · 01-03-13, 17:24

Iam a huge Floyd fan and this video is one of my faves its kinda like comfortably numb but this video was takin at the concert i went to see in 2006 seen them twice Classssss seen the wall live too last year and got my ticket to see it again this year in the aviva

cant wait ohhh yeah best show on earth people are always shocked when i say my fav band is floyd cause i am aparantly to young to like them lol 26 to young

**johnnybbad** · 01-03-13, 17:28

Originally Posted by Martin Mod

Pink Floyd after Roger Waters left seem more of a tribute band. Gilmour could never written anything of the genius of Waters

that depends on the person my favourit album is the division bell and waters had nothing to do with it

and just look at the final cut which was a pink floyd lp gilmour didnt even want his name on it they picked the wall to do over it and his solo lp was very war esq and very political so he would have takin floyd in a shit direction if you ask me

**Martin Ward** · 01-03-13, 17:32

Originally Posted by johnnybbad

that depends on the person my favourit album is the division bell and waters had nothing to do with it

and just look at the final cut which was a pink floyd lp gilmour didnt even want his name on it the picked the wall to do over it and his solo lp was very war esq and very political so he would have takin floy in a shit direction if you ask me

Opinions opinions opinions. But I feel a momentary Lapse of Reason and the Division Bell are bland. Most peoples faves here are by Waters

**johnnybbad** · 01-03-13, 17:41

Originally Posted by Martin Mod

Opinions opinions opinions. But I feel a momentary Lapse of Reason and the Division Bell are bland. Most peoples faves here are by Waters

Ah dont get me wrong of course its opinion and most people do favour the waters songs and i do love them all but i have so many favs on divison bell i agree with you momentary is very bland one slip and one or two others are really good gilmour was never a songwriter by no means but i think he came out the better he was able to carry on the floyd name and its good to see him a waters starting to make amens

Thread: Pink Floyd x

Thread Tools

Search Thread

Display

The Following User Says Thank You to wolfie For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to thewren For This Useful Post:

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Stephanie For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to Stephanie For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to Clyde For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to mellors For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to johnnybbad For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to johnnybbad For This Useful Post:

The Following User Says Thank You to Martin Ward For This Useful Post:

Posting Permissions