Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 26

Thread: More Review Statistics

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    In a cathouse
    Posts
    3,548
    Blog Entries
    1
    Reviews
    26

    Default More Review Statistics

    My previous thread about reviews https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...views-not.html seems to have wandered a bit off topic, so I am posting a new one. Most people's intuition is that reviewers with few reviews are often fake. In that thread I posted some statistical evidence in support of this. Unfortunately, counting one time reviewers is not a very reliable way to identify escorts with fake reviews. There just isn't enough data for most escorts.

    There is a much better number to use, but it takes a bit of effort to compute: The median number of reviews for her reviewers. What does that mean? Consider Eve. If we go through her reviews and count the number of reviews each reviewer has, and then put them in order, we get these numbers: 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 5 5 5 5 5 6 6 7 8 9 10 10 11 11 11 12 12 13 13 13 17 18 18 21 21 29 29 29 36 36 36 36 74. I've marked the number in the middle, which is 11. Half of her reviewers have at least that many reviews. This number is the median number of reviews for her reviewers. In general, a higher number is better. As you'll see below, 11 is a very good number.

    In general, the higher this number is the more reliable the reviews.
    As a measure of reliability of reviews, the median number of reviews for her reviewers has three big advantages:
    - It's really hard for an escort to fake it. In Eve's case, if she wanted to raise this number she would have to create several accounts and write at least a dozen reviews from each.
    - For most escorts it doesn't change much if we add or remove a few reviews. For example, Eve seems to have attracted a disturbed individual who wrote several reviews under various usernames. Those have been ratted. I haven't removed them from the list above, but it doesn't matter much; Removing them would only change the median from 11 to 12.
    - It's pretty reliable even for escorts who don't have a large number of reviews. I would tend to trust it even for escorts who only have 15-20 reviews.

    It's a bit of a pain to compute. Fortunately for you, I've computed it for all the escorts with at least 15 reviews, so you don't have to.

    Before I give the numbers, there are three biases to be aware of:
    - It's biased against new escorts. You can see from the list below that most of the escorts at the high end are either retired or have been here for a long time. There are several reasons for this bias, and there's not much I can do about it.
    - It's biased against escorts who see at lot of new clients. It's not quite as bad as counting one time reviewers, but the bias is still there. Again, there is not much I can do about this.
    - It's biased against escorts who are unlucky. I said that for most escorts it doesn't change much if we add or remove a few reviews. There are exceptions, like Anna. The numbers of reviews her reviewers have written are: 1 2 5 5 10 10 10 11 12 12 16 16 21 21 21 38 38 38 74. A median of 12 is very good, but she just barely misses 16.
    It is very damaging for a new escort who sees a lot of new clients and who is just on the wrong side of a big jump in the number of reviews. I know Karin reads these threads closely, and she will point out that this is exactly her case.

    I haven't removed rats or duplicates. That's mostly laziness on my part.

    As always, no statistical measure can substitute for reading the reviews!

    Now for the numbers. They vary a lot. Anywhere from 1 to 21! I've grouped them by median. Within each group the order is random. I've linked reviews rather than profiles so you can see escorts who have retired or who aren't advertising at the moment. Note that there are often several escorts with the same name; make sure you know which one you are looking at.

    “I wish you wouldn’t keep appearing and vanishing so suddenly; you make one quite giddy!”
    “All right,” said the Cat; and this time it vanished quite slowly, beginning with the end of the tail, and ending with the grin, which remained some time after the rest of it had gone.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    In a cathouse
    Posts
    3,548
    Blog Entries
    1
    Reviews
    26

    Default The Numbers, Part I

    21
    Escort Reviews of Cassie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    20
    Escort Reviews of Alexi Diamond, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    19
    Escort Reviews of Melissa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    18
    Escort Reviews of Julia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    17
    Escort Reviews of Alexis, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ashley, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Nelly, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    16
    Escort Reviews of Susie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    15
    Escort Reviews of Busty Malena, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Rebecca, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    14
    Escort Reviews of Kat, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    13
    Escort Reviews of Mia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Beauty Michelle, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sexy Janet, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Paola, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Romy, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    12
    Escort Reviews of Brigitte, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Julia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Nina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Anna, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Jessie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Karla, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sexy Brigitte, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ksenija, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Abi, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Joylyn, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Julieta, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    11
    Escort Reviews of Tereza, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Gaby, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Lilly, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ivet, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sofie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Mature Silke, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Eve, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Saffron Uk, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sonia Barcelona, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sasha Eve, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    10
    Escort Reviews of Bellinha, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Vivien, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sophya, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sarah, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Antonella, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Diana M, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Shakira, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Violette, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of English Rebecca, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of TiffanyTees, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Alyssa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Bea, Irish escort from Escort Ireland

    “I wish you wouldn’t keep appearing and vanishing so suddenly; you make one quite giddy!”
    “All right,” said the Cat; and this time it vanished quite slowly, beginning with the end of the tail, and ending with the grin, which remained some time after the rest of it had gone.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    In a cathouse
    Posts
    3,548
    Blog Entries
    1
    Reviews
    26

    Default

    9
    Escort Reviews of Jessica James, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Denise, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Leticia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ana Cristina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Lucy Brazil, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sexy Alesia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Gemma, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Aida, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Diams, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Naomi, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Vanessa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sexy Angelina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sara, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Adriana Cavalli, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    8
    Escort Reviews of Sophie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Chantel, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Veronica, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Nikky, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Adriana, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Michelle, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Janet, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Daria Hot, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Lauren, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Nikki, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Taylor of Manchester, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Grabriely, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Lynne, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Charlotte of Westminster, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Top Christine, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Satine, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    7
    Escort Reviews of Jessica, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sisi, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ava Green, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Rubina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sexy Iris, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Agnieszka, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Tasha , Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Maria Antoinette, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Fiona(Irish), Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Paula Barcelona, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Viky, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Emotion, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Angelina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Flora, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ruth, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Diana, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Francesca, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Savanna36FF, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sindya, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Yasmina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Monica, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Natalie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Claudia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Alina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Toni, Irish escort from Escort Ireland

    “I wish you wouldn’t keep appearing and vanishing so suddenly; you make one quite giddy!”
    “All right,” said the Cat; and this time it vanished quite slowly, beginning with the end of the tail, and ending with the grin, which remained some time after the rest of it had gone.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    In a cathouse
    Posts
    3,548
    Blog Entries
    1
    Reviews
    26

    Default The Numbers, Part III

    6
    Escort Reviews of Layla, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ana Savicha, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Victoria, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Celine, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Heidi, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Julie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Mature Abby, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Savana, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Amu, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Ema, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Karana, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Selena, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Elly, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Brown Sugar, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Rachel, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Adriana, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Vivian, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Veny, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Vanes, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Mara, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Annie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Yume, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Isabel, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Leah, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of English Sophie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of English Taylor, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Mature Betty, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    5
    Escort Reviews of Angelina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Laiza, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Agatha, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Caterine, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Michelle Mature, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Elle, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Rhianna, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Patty Baby, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Nykitta , Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Charlie, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sandy, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Melisa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Larissa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Great Kamilla, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Abigail (mature), Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Blanca, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sexy Cindy, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Evelyn, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Clair, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sabrina Lovely, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sara D8, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Sara, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Georgina, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Emma, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Leticia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Valery, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Alexis, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Monica, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Anne Claire, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Lucia, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Bruna, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Penelope, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Yolanda, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Amora Brazil, Irish escort from Escort Ireland

    “I wish you wouldn’t keep appearing and vanishing so suddenly; you make one quite giddy!”
    “All right,” said the Cat; and this time it vanished quite slowly, beginning with the end of the tail, and ending with the grin, which remained some time after the rest of it had gone.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Posts
    996
    Blog Entries
    1

    Post

    Quote Originally Posted by El Gordo View Post

    In general, the higher this number is the more reliable the reviews.

    As always, no statistical measure can substitute for reading the reviews!

    Excellent work again El Gordo !!! I am very confident you are going to find eventually a fool proof scientific way to calculate the credibility of escort reviews, I am just not very sure that the median number is the solution.

    The median number could indeed be a very useful tool for calculating the reliability of some escorts.
    Why am I saying some instead of all? Because in my opinion, this number would help you decide indeed between some relatively new escorts with only a few reviews and for which no other reliable information is available (like recommendation, lady's own postings etc). If you have to chose between escort A, escort B and escort C (with the reviews as below, there is indeed a much better chance for you to pick escort C in this case:

    Escort A: 1, 1, 2, 3, 4.
    Escort B: 1, 1, 3, 5, 6.
    Escort C: 1, 3, 5, 8, 10.

    However, the situation complicates a lot when you have to decide between escorts with more reviews. Take for example Mellisa, Kat and Alyssa:

    Escort Reviews of Melissa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Kat, Irish escort from Escort Ireland
    Escort Reviews of Alyssa, Irish escort from Escort Ireland

    Based on your stats, the reviews reliability for these ladies would be:

    1 st place: Melissa
    2nd place: Kat
    3rd place: Alyssa

    Well, looking trough their reviews we can see for a start that Melissa has a total of 30 reviews, from which:

    - 10 ratted positive reviews
    - 15 positive reviews
    - 2 negative reviews
    - 1 neutral review
    - 1 N/A review

    In comparation, Kat would have 21 reviews, from which:

    - 1 single ratted positive review
    - 19 positive reviews
    - 1 negative reviews

    Alyssa's situation for her 70 reviews:

    - 1 single ratted negative review
    - 68 positive reviews
    - 1 N/A review

    In conclusion: the median number cannot be used to check if escort reviews are more reliable then others. Who would be more credible, an escort with a third of her reviews ratted & 50 % positive unrated reviews (Mellisa) or an escort with 90 % positive unrated reviews (Kat) or another escort with 97 % of positive unrated reviews (Alyssa) ???


    P.S. In reality, as the ladies I picked as an example here have each a sufficient number of reviews to make them very credible as escorts, a punter will see any of the ladies I picked as an example based on how attractive he would find them, their price and their availability. If I am allowed to quote Mr Jolly's joke that he made on your previous thread about reviews: "after several computations, permutation etc ... the one I'm going to see tonite is ... the one with bigger tits ".

    P.P.S. I really find your work, your time & efforts simply excellent and I do apologise if my reply to your thread may seem like I contest them. I firmly believe that scientific measures could be useful in this case, I just think that something as simple as the median number is not a measure powerful enough to be applied across all reviews and escorts.

    (Currently posting using ID "Sensual Delights")

  6. #6
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    5,362

    Smile Get a room you two...

    El Gordo and Karin.

    Hats off and kudos to both but please promise us you two won't team up for the new interview competition.... My head hurts...

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    5,442

    Default

    Excellent work again Brother El Gordo.....I can see that you put a lot of thought, time and effort into the statistical analyses of escort reviews and also well done to Karin for her insightful contribution. This could develop into a very usefull thread. My own view, would be that some sort of a formula needs to be devised which takes account of a number of different factors....the desirability of including/excluding compleatly the ratted reviews and N/As is another area for debate.

    If you were to take your median value for each escort and contruct a database of these, you would be able to translate these figures into percentile values e.g. an escort with a median of 12 for example, would score better than say 60% of escorts on this measure.

    Keep up the good work.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    393
    Reviews
    35

    Default

    Great work but I think that the results are distorted by multiple reviews from high-number reviewers. Fori nsteance, an escort with only three reviews but all from Skankman would have a number of 108!!!

  9. #9
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Deep down in the E-I dungeon
    Posts
    11,634
    Reviews
    29

    Default

    Very good work El Gordo.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    5,442

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by adogwithabone View Post
    Great work but I think that the results are distorted by multiple reviews from high-number reviewers. Fori nsteance, an escort with only three reviews but all from Skankman would have a number of 108!!!
    Or even if that escort only had one review and it was from Skankman, the value would still be 108.
    But those sort of scores would be exceptional and would be way off a normal distribution curve and should therefore be ignored.

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •