Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Sex and Irish media hypocrisy

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Location
    Away
    Posts
    784
    Reviews
    6

    Default Sex and Irish media hypocrisy

    So as we are already aware Former US President Jimmy Carter has come out in support of the 'Turn off the red light' campaign, a matter which was discussed on today's Drive Time on RTE One radio. Presenter Mary Wilson brought on Denise Charlton from the Immigrant Council of Ireland to discuss the matter, a link to the show is here starting 1 hour 39 minutes in http://www.rte.ie/radio/utils/radiop...2D09%2D2014%3A


    Now typical I would expect the usual bias towards sex work and the people involved but a recent ruling by the BAI (Broadcasting Authority of Ireland) in regards to Derek Mooney show on the matter of same sex marriages is just highlighting how the narrow minded and bias our conservative media is.

    To put into context the Derek Mooney show had a segment on the number of civil partnerships in Ireland, the contents of which related person experience of guest on the shows experience with civil partnership in Ireland. A complaint was made to the BAI on the grounds that the presenter did not challenge the guest position or opinions which the BAI upheld the complaint on the grounds of breaching 'Objectivity/Impartiality in News, Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in Current Affairs'. Although the segment discussion did not involve or discuss the referendum on same-sex unions the BAI upheld the complaint on the grounds that the segment constituted current affairs content on an issue of current public debate and so there were requirements of fairness, objectivity and impartiality governing the segment and that these had not been met due to the lack of representative voice against same sex marriages.

    Here is the section on the BAI website about Objectivity/Impartiality in News, Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in Current Affairs
    "All broadcast news must be presented and reported in an objective and impartial manner and without expression of the broadcasters’ own views. Current affairs broadcasts, including matters of public controversy or debate, must be treated in a manner which is fair to all interests concerned and the broadcast must be presented in an objective and impartial manner, without any expression of the broadcasters’ own views."

    So having listened to today's Drive Time, which if you haven't please do, you can understand my annoyances that a piece that is actively targeted at a current public debate was allowed to carry such bias and one side debate. The presenter Mary Wilson not once challenged Denise Charlton position or asked for figures, instead her questions only served as a platform for Denise Charlton to speak on. At no point was even the notion of consensual sex workers brought up by either the presenter or her guest, from their perspective all sex worker were here against their will, whether through substance abuse, financial or physical pressure, with claims that most sex workers entered into sex work at age of 14, another 'fact' that went unchallenged by Mary Wilson.

    Now I know I am bias and despite my own very positive interactions with escorting I do know however that this is not true for all. Trafficking exist, it is a serious problem which anyone aware or suspicious of has a duty to inform the relevant authorities but the portrayal of all involved both client and escort was overwhelmingly negative, the mere fact that the presenter of Drive Time had not even one question opposing Denise Charlton is insane.

    I feel I should at this point that I would say deep down I have certain belief in my religion but even though I have I am dumbfounded to find the religious beliefs and organization can and are dictating so much of our lives in legislation. Given the seemly unending scandal of child sex abuse, neglect leading to death and the imprisonment and slavery of unmarried mothers under religious organizations that they should be acting in any capacity as moral authority backing these campaigns is unbelievable. Gay marriage is seen as such a controversial subject but at the end of the day why does it matter to society if the two consenting adults are of different sex or not. The same flawed moral judgement is been made in regards to sex work, that regardless if both are consenting adults that somehow because it does not fit the moral ethos base on personal beliefs of some it is allowed to negate the personal freedom of others. Yet here we are with our public (and publicly funded) media legitimizing one side of the debate, if this had been opposite where someone came to speak on behalf of the sex industry I can assure you the host would have actively and maybe even aggressively questioned the guest then the passive reinforcement of one side that we go today.

    /rant
    Last edited by Deven; 01-09-14 at 21:29.
    The beauty of the internet is that there is always a 'close' button.

  2. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Deven For This Useful Post:

    Curvaceous Kate (01-09-14), Davidontour (02-09-14), JMastodon (02-09-14), mymann (02-09-14), Paul Carr (02-09-14), Rocker123 (02-09-14), the traveller (02-09-14), zoozoozoo (02-09-14)

  3. #2
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Way out West
    Posts
    2,040
    Reviews
    53

    Default

    Deven,- Agree totally with your post.
    I heard the interview live and kept thinking, now why is Mary Wilson not asking Denise Charlton," Why are those involved in organized crime that are managing and forcing children and young women into this Country for prostitution not reported to the relevant authorities and prosecuted".
    Denise seemed to know who these people are and we do not need new legislation to deal with organized crime, or do we ?

  4. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to mymann For This Useful Post:

    Davidontour (02-09-14), Deven (02-09-14), The Equalizer (02-09-14)

  5. #3
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    Belfast / Beal Feirste / Capital of Norn Iron
    Posts
    1,118
    Reviews
    5

    Default

    Not so much a debate as a propaganda piece. No-one can blame Charlton for pushing her sales pitch -- money is important to us all and if she can secure funding via lies and half-truths, then fair play to her for trying. But the 'Drive Time' bias on the issue is quite breath-taking and falls far short of what should be expected from a major broadcaster.

    As for Jimmy Carter, perhaps he should consider that (other than a few parts of Nevada) buying and selling sexual services has been illegal in the US for a century, yet official figures estimate the number of sex workers at well over 1 million, with $14 billion generated overall. A 2004 TNS poll reported 15 percent of all men have paid for sex and 30 percent of single men over age 30 have paid for sex.

    In other words, criminalisation simply doesn't work. What it does is give the appearance of doing something and provides lucrative funding for the laughably named 'rescue industry.'
    2014 in Northern Ireland:

    Number of reported attacks on sex workers 70

    Number of sex trafficking cases ZERO

  6. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Davidontour For This Useful Post:

    Deven (02-09-14), JMastodon (02-09-14), mymann (03-09-14)

  7. #4
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Posts
    293

  8. #5
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Location
    Away
    Posts
    784
    Reviews
    6

    Default

    First thought, quickly followed by the fact you cant complain anonymously, given the stigma associated with escorting would you like to put your name to paper?
    The beauty of the internet is that there is always a 'close' button.

  9. #6
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    1,913
    Reviews
    2

    Default

    Derek 220K per year Mooney, recently got into trouble with the BAI over wishing a gay couple well and hoping that they would be able to married in the future! Now it was a nonsense of the BAI to do that, but surely this is significant! COMPLAIN!
    Ride them on the beaches!

  10. #7
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    1,913
    Reviews
    2

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Deven View Post
    First thought, quickly followed by the fact you cant complain anonymously, given the stigma associated with escorting would you like to put your name to paper?
    It's not about the punter, it's about protecting sex workers' lives which along with increasing funding for ICI and Ruhama this law is evidently aimed at destroying!
    Ride them on the beaches!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •