Is torture ever okay

[tony1]

I have just watch zero dark thirty.

[Jiberjabber]

No, it's never okay. It's an act of barbarism whose only true value is instilling fear in your enemy. The Americans knew they'd get no useful information from torture, that was never the point.


Rubbish movie by the way.

[SmallHorn]

Id have to say yes.


There is some bad cunts out there whom I would happily torture.

[Jiberjabber]

I'm cynical, but not that much. Muppets in charge IMHO.

Lets be clear hear all the criticism is not coming from us but elements in there own society.

The criticism is coming from most civilised countries in the free world. They are in contravention of the Geneva convention. If they had proof of one instance of the torture having worked to stop some planned attack we'd be hearing about it 24/7 on prime time accompanied by all the usual flag- waving jingoisms

[Walshie]

No, but then I go and inflict torture on others here..........................with my threads

[Jiberjabber]

Am I suppose to reconsider the American position based on some Irish history or something? Sorry bud but I'm shit out of guilt and patriotic fervour, that stuff is for chumps.

[Jiberjabber]

Yes, yes it's a good comeback. But not based on reality I think.

G'wan ta fuck, you're only arguing for the sake of it now

[SmallHorn]

G'wan ta fuck, you're only arguing for the sake of it now

He got owned in the other thread.

Hes a chancer

[Jiberjabber]

He got owned in the other thread.

Hes a chancer

Ah. He's on a mission to reclaim some dignity then. I'll leave him to argue with himself so.

[funlover12]

Id have to say yes.


There is some bad cunts out there whom I would happily torture.

the dirt bird?