Case; E-I Members vs. Fake Reviewers

OK E-I Members and Staff,

Here are my findings and conclusion. I will start from the begining of my findings by date. These will be listed as facts and then my conculsion/theory of the events will follow.

2/10/08 Irishcolm registers. He posts a review on Layla; Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 006696 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

27/01/09 12:20am Irishcolm posts an advert:

hi girls,

im horny 24/7 and so im offering hot sex for all you beautiful women, whether your in your late teens or are middle aged. i will you give a fantastic buzzing orgasm, im irish, fit and 23 years old. call or text me on (removed number)

The Ad was deleted by Sarah.

27/01/09 12:52am Irishcolm posts a thread looking for feedback on male escort work. He lists his age again as 23.... https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...le-escort.html

27/01/09 01:13am Irishcolm post in the Greedy Escorts thread:

i completely agree, its ridicolous what escorts are charging in this country, many men earn 10 euro an hour, thats if they can have a job whilst escorts charge 200-300 per hour and as im only 23 they certainly enjoyed the hour too. its terribly dishonest, with the polish conversion rates, it means eastern europeans here are getting 600% more for their services than in east europe. these escorts are taking advantage of irish men.. its absolute greed. holland, the uk and everywhere else is cheaper.

so if a girl does 10 hours at 250euro per hour in a week thats 2500euro in a week, god ive worked long hard 50 hour weeks in recent years for less than 500euro. how can all you escorts justify this? what to hell do you need all this money for-drugs i suppose? you all really should be ashamed of yourselves, selling yourselfs for sex-thats pure evil, us irish are catholic and women like you all will have serious questions to answer when you die and meet your creator

Thread link: https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...s-started.html

18/02/09 Irishcolm reviews Patty Baby: Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009247 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

05/03/09 Irishcolm posts for the last time making an angry comment: https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...k-tonight.html

7/03/09 Irishcolm reviews Patty Baby for the second time: Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009680 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

12/03/09 Irishcolm reviews Patty Baby for the third time: Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009803 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

Also on the 12/03/09 Paul.Burkee, Youngman and Youngg1979 all register and post reviews on Patty Baby.

Patty Baby reviews : Escort Reviews of Patty Baby, Irish escort from Escort Ireland

14/03/09 Paul.Burkee posts a coment in Hottest Nationality: https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...earchid=309271

14/03/09 Paul.Burkee reviews Patty Baby Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009871 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

17/03/09 Irishcolm reviews Layla
Paul.Burkee reviews Layla
Youngg1979 reviews Layla
Youngman reviews Giulia

Colinbest1985 registers and reviews Layla, Patty Baby, Andrada and Giulia. Reviews of Irish escorts written by Irish escort client colinbest1985 - Escort Ireland
Conor23xxx registers and reviews Patty Baby twice, Layla and Giulia. Reviews of Irish escorts written by Irish escort client conor23xxxx - Escort Ireland

18/03/09 Tomconefry and Hornysean44 registered and reviewed Giulia. Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009961 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies
Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009963 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

Those are the facts.


Theory/Conclusion
Well its pretty clear to see that there's a pattern here. Irishcolm I assume is either 2 of the other profiles or all of them. A lot of the grammer/spelling in the reviews indicate that its the same person or possibly two. Tracing these profiles back from paddys has ended up at Irishcolm's door.

I have written to all of these profiles asking about information involving their bookings. I have also written to Patricia and Sarah asking to check their IP.

In the meantime until they can prove that their reviews are coincidental I am not counting them in Escort of the Month. That means Patty Baby is still in the lead with 24 points instead of 42. Also Giulia's, Layla's and Andrada's won't be counted either.

I am not closing the competition down at all. I assume Patty Baby will win this month for the second time. I don't think she is cheating. I think that we have a guy that might like Latin girls too much and is faking reviews. Patty Baby has seen a lot of trusty reviewers and has a lot of support here. She doen't need fake reviews, unless your trying to damage her.

Ric:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RicFlair

OK E-I Members and Staff,

Here are my findings and conclusion. I will start from the begining of my findings by date. These will be listed as facts and then my conculsion/theory of the events will follow.

2/10/08 Irishcolm registers. He posts a review on Layla; Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 006696 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

27/01/09 12:20am Irishcolm posts an advert:

hi girls,

im horny 24/7 and so im offering hot sex for all you beautiful women, whether your in your late teens or are middle aged. i will you give a fantastic buzzing orgasm, im irish, fit and 23 years old. call or text me on (removed number)

The Ad was deleted by Sarah.

27/01/09 12:52am Irishcolm posts a thread looking for feedback on male escort work. He lists his age again as 23.... https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...le-escort.html

27/01/09 01:13am Irishcolm post in the Greedy Escorts thread:

i completely agree, its ridicolous what escorts are charging in this country, many men earn 10 euro an hour, thats if they can have a job whilst escorts charge 200-300 per hour and as im only 23 they certainly enjoyed the hour too. its terribly dishonest, with the polish conversion rates, it means eastern europeans here are getting 600% more for their services than in east europe. these escorts are taking advantage of irish men.. its absolute greed. holland, the uk and everywhere else is cheaper.

so if a girl does 10 hours at 250euro per hour in a week thats 2500euro in a week, god ive worked long hard 50 hour weeks in recent years for less than 500euro. how can all you escorts justify this? what to hell do you need all this money for-drugs i suppose? you all really should be ashamed of yourselves, selling yourselfs for sex-thats pure evil, us irish are catholic and women like you all will have serious questions to answer when you die and meet your creator

Thread link: https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...s-started.html

18/02/09 Irishcolm reviews Patty Baby: Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009247 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

05/03/09 Irishcolm posts for the last time making an angry comment: https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...k-tonight.html

7/03/09 Irishcolm reviews Patty Baby for the second time: Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009680 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

12/03/09 Irishcolm reviews Patty Baby for the third time: Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009803 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

Also on the 12/03/09 Paul.Burkee, Youngman and Youngg1979 all register and post reviews on Patty Baby.

Patty Baby reviews : Escort Reviews of Patty Baby, Irish escort from Escort Ireland

14/03/09 Paul.Burkee posts a coment in Hottest Nationality: https://www.escort-ireland.com/board...earchid=309271

14/03/09 Paul.Burkee reviews Patty Baby Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009871 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

17/03/09 Irishcolm reviews Layla
Paul.Burkee reviews Layla
Youngg1979 reviews Layla
Youngman reviews Giulia

Colinbest1985 registers and reviews Layla, Patty Baby, Andrada and Giulia. Reviews of Irish escorts written by Irish escort client colinbest1985 - Escort Ireland
Conor23xxx registers and reviews Patty Baby twice, Layla and Giulia. Reviews of Irish escorts written by Irish escort client conor23xxxx - Escort Ireland

18/03/09 Tomconefry and Hornysean44 registered and reviewed Giulia. Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009961 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies
Escort Ireland - Escort Reviews - Review 009963 - Irish Independent Escorts, Irish Touring Escorts, Irish Escort Agencies

Those are the facts.


Theory/Conclusion
Well its pretty clear to see that there's a pattern here. Irishcolm I assume is either 2 of the other profiles or all of them. A lot of the grammer/spelling in the reviews indicate that its the same person or possibly two. Tracing these profiles back from paddys has ended up at Irishcolm's door.

I have written to all of these profiles asking about information involving their bookings. I have also written to Patricia and Sarah asking to check their IP.

In the meantime until they can prove that their reviews are coincidental I am not counting them in Escort of the Month. That means Patty Baby is still in the lead with 24 points instead of 42. Also Giulia's, Layla's and Andrada's won't be counted either.

I am not closing the competition down at all. I assume Patty Baby will win this month for the second time. I don't think she is cheating. I think that we have a guy that might like Latin girls too much and is faking reviews. Patty Baby has seen a lot of trusty reviewers and has a lot of support here. She doen't need fake reviews, unless your trying to damage her.

Ric:)

---

WOW:eek:, that's making a point!
I have seen reviews of Paty Baby,all of them positive, regularly posted every 2,3 days-it looks impossible not to get even one bad review,she must be more then lucky.
I did not realized that Irishcolm may use more than one account here but remember his post on the forum,then his review for Paty Baby.I have check IP addresses before and they are all clear no connection,but style of writing,same grammar mistakes will proved your theory.
Yesterday we have received around 15 reviews from

Paul.Burkee reviews Layla
Youngg1979 reviews Layla
Youngman reviews Giulia
...all of them left just for 2 escorts, they have not been approved yet but will update them later on today.
Thanks for very hard work.:)
Sarah

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RicFlair

I am not closing the competition down at all. I assume Patty Baby will win this month for the second time. I don't think she is cheating. I think that we have a guy that might like Latin girls too much and is faking reviews. Patty Baby has seen a lot of trusty reviewers and has a lot of support here. She doen't need fake reviews, unless your trying to damage her.

Ric:)

---

But would u agree that she is trying to manipulte the reveiw system in order to gain free advertisting , it would curious to find out her relationship with Andrada.

I too myself checked her reviews ,and other than the ones by regular reviewersand the ones mentioned above ,there are a lot from first time register/reviewers.

nbt

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ninebythree

But would u agree that she is trying to manipulte the reveiw system in order to gain free advertisting , it would curious to find out her relationship with Andrada.

I too myself checked her reviews ,and other than the ones by regular reviewersand the ones mentioned above ,there are a lot from first time register/reviewers.

nbt

---

Its difficult to say Nb3. I don't think she's behind it. Although it looks like we have a pimp or an overly fixated reviewer that likes Latin pussy. All these girls involved it the case are Brazilian,Spanish ect. Maybe they did visit theses girls but not all at the same time. I'm in one of two minds at keeping Patty in this months competition. I might have to disqualify her from this months competiton untill things become more clear.

So far none of the profiles have written back to me, but its early days.

Also as for the other new profiles that reviewed Patty and the others. Yes a couple seem suspect. But the 9 I've pointed out are the most suspect.

Also I like Pats Bodyguard's idea of verified reviews. I must some how incorporate that into the competition.:)

Ric xxx :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RicFlair

Its difficult to say Nb3. I don't think she's behind it. Although it looks like we have a pimp or an overly fixated reviewer that likes Latin pussy. All these girls involved it the case are Brazilian,Spanish ect. Maybe they did visit theses girls but not all at the same time. I'm in one of two minds at keeping Patty in this months competition. I might have to disqualify her from this months competiton untill things become more clear.

So far none of the profiles have written back to me, but its early days.

Also as for the other new profiles that reviewed Patty and the others. Yes a couple seem suspect. But the 9 I've pointed out are the most suspect.

Also I like Pats Bodyguard's idea of verified reviews. I must some how incorporate that into the competition.:)

Ric xxx :)

---

Thanks for listening Ric :D

Now, how about the final nominated escorts having to say, in less than 250 words

Why they THINK they deserve escort of the month!

Then post it as a Poll and let us vote on that! :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ninebythree

But would u agree that she is trying to manipulte the reveiw system in order to gain free advertisting , it would curious to find out her relationship with Andrada.

I too myself checked her reviews ,and other than the ones by regular reviewersand the ones mentioned above ,there are a lot from first time register/reviewers.

nbt

---

Hi Nine

I spoke to Patty today it is some gobshite trying to ingratiate himself with these escorts she has no connection with the other escorts that this guy has reviewed. She is not pimped does not work for an agency and she assures me she never asked him to write these reviews in fact she has texted the guy she is fairly sure it is asking him to stop.
Interestingly he never wrote any for the girl she shares an apartment with which would be the obvious sign if it was either the escort or a pimp.

ok everyone, i wrote these reviews, all were genuine, genuine in the sense that all good reviews were given for a reason, the escorts in question were all visited, several times and a good service was always recieved by all.. i dont write reviews regulary so when i do, i write alot although they're usually over several months punting.. it certainly seemed that writing loads of reviews using the same name would be suspect so foolishly i made differnet names.. i am a punter and have no association/relationship with any of those i reviewed, therefore theres no 'conflict of interest' here..

granted alot of good reviews at once appeared suspect but everything i wrote, although under different names was true, i do like to complement a good service and i feel this is only fair to the girls..

patty baby in particular is a diamond and was visited up to a dozen times by me so i did feel it was only fair to compliment a good time with positive and complementary reviews..

ok i do accept i was irresponsible in having more than 1 user account but look at this from my point of view:------ which would seem more inapprotiate, 1 username giving say 30 genuine positive reviews or say 5-10 different users giving 30 positive reviews????

i have to say i'm at fault here, i put my hands up and take responsibility, i'm not bullshiting and trying to deny anything at all.. im being open and genuine about this.. it seems unfair to have a rat alongside these reviews, ok they are from the same person (me fein) but each one does represent a genuine visit and the reciept of a good and well-enjoyed service from the girls.. it would seem terribly unfair to me that these girls should have to have their webpages tarnished with my silly mistake---its only fair that these rat symbols are removed, all my reviews are completely genuine, dates are estimates as i've crap memory, the only thing here is that i have different usernames!!!

thanks all and my apologies once again!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stewie

Hi Nine

I spoke to Patty today it is some gobshite trying to ingratiate himself with these escorts she has no connection with the other escorts that this guy has reviewed. She is not pimped does not work for an agency and she assures me she never asked him to write these reviews in fact she has texted the guy she is fairly sure it is asking him to stop.
Interestingly he never wrote any for the girl she shares an apartment with which would be the obvious sign if it was either the escort or a pimp.

---

I not suggesting that there was a pimp involved . Realistically what answer did u expect to get from her ....." Yes ric , i wrote the fake reviews so i could win escort of the month and avail of free advertising " :rolleyes:
ps whos the other girl

nbt

Colm is supposedly 23, complains about the amount escorts charge here and what he assumes their weekly earnings must be, then starts to have a go at them for theological reasons. And finally he now seems to be spending an absolute fortunate on a small number of regular shags.......maybe his vocation in life is to become the "Father of the Nation" and he's in practice now.

Does anybody out there believe this bs?

But hey.....I could always be wrong myself....those that the years dont age and wither, just become cynical.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ninebythree

I not suggesting that there was a pimp involved . Realistically what answer did u expect to get from her ....." Yes ric , i wrote the fake reviews so i could win escort of the month and avail of free advertising " :rolleyes:
ps whos the other girl

nbt

---

No nine but the guy has admitted it and the girls involved don't appear to have any link for example their various partners are not reviewed by this guy.
I just think that we should not jump to the conclusion that the girls had anything to do with this unless you can find some link between them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stewie

No nine but the guy has admitted it and the girls involved don't appear to have any link for example their various partners are not reviewed by this guy.
I just think that we should not jump to the conclusion that the girls had anything to do with this unless you can find some link between them.

---

cal

Do you honestly believe him , why come on here an admit to being an ass. Would you not admit that he fessed up to deflect attention away .

I also agree we shouldnt jump to the conclusions but ask yourself ,who has the most to gain from winning escort of the month.


nbt

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ninebythree

cal

Do you honestly believe him , why come on here an admit to being an ass. Would you not admit that he fessed up to deflect attention away .

I also agree we shouldnt jump to the conclusions but ask yourself ,who has the most to gain from winning escort of the month.


nbt

---

Because he is a gobshite


Just because someone may gain from something does not mean they had anything to do with it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stewie

Because he is a gobshite


Just because someone may gain from something does not mean they had anything to do with it.

---

but it doesnt mean they hadnt either:D


nbt

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ninebythree

but it doesnt mean they hadnt either:D


nbt

---

Yeah but given that there is nothing to suggest they had anything to do with it its a little unfair that they are tarnished by it

If Patty had anything to do with it surely she would have got a few reviews for her Duo partner Manu

god i cant believe the jury is out on this one, the above text is 100%

i cant understand how u lads are still cynical and suspicious!


theres no link between these girls, they're just loads of reviews from loads of seperate punts...... i do have luck now and again on the horses and we all have our own methods of finding a buzz..nothing suspect or unusual about that....

i think it would be fair either to delete all my reviews although each oe does represent a single genuine punt over 2 months or so and since they all represent different punts, i suppose why should be either deleted or have a rat with them? afterall its a minority of you pricks who started all this by questioning the credibility of my various reviews---its time ye all woke up and smell the crap.......DREAMON seems to have started all this so what has he to say for himself?? its bad form to be questioning another punters reviews.. im sure lots of lads sitdown now and again and write several reviews on the same day about various punts made over previous months!!!!!!! we dont all be on here 24/7 like some of you tossers out there!!!!!!!!

your verdict----RIC????????

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by irishcolm

god i cant believe the jury is out on this one, the above text is 100%

i cant understand how u lads are still cynical and suspicious!


theres no link between these girls, they're just loads of reviews from loads of seperate punts...... i do have luck now and again on the horses and we all have our own methods of finding a buzz..nothing suspect or unusual about that....

i think it would be fair either to delete all my reviews although each oe does represent a single genuine punt over 2 months or so and since they all represent different punts, i suppose why should be either deleted or have a rat with them? afterall its a minority of you pricks who started all this by questioning the credibility of my various reviews---its time ye all woke up and smell the crap.......DREAMON seems to have started all this so what has he to say for himself?? its bad form to be questioning another punters reviews.. im sure lots of lads sitdown now and again and write several reviews on the same day about various punts made over previous months!!!!!!! we dont all be on here 24/7 like some of you tossers out there!!!!!!!!

your verdict----RIC????????

---

:mad:

irish colm up for maggot of the the month!!!!!!!

how about a rule- one week to post a review, if you cant do it within that dont bother.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by billyjt

how about a rule- one week to post a review, if you cant do it within that dont bother.

---

As things stand, this would be a problem for touring escorts. The way the system works now, if you see a touring escort on the last day of her tour and her profile is gone before you get a chance to review her then your next chance to post the review will be whenever she comes back, possibly weeks or months later.

I would suggest changing the review system to allow reviews of escorts whose profiles have been suspended within the last few days, and then changing the time limit as you suggest. It would be fairer on the escorts, since they have a much better chance of rebutting a recent bad review than an old one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stewie

No nine but the guy has admitted it and the girls involved don't appear to have any link for example their various partners are not reviewed by this guy.
I just think that we should not jump to the conclusion that the girls had anything to do with this unless you can find some link between them.

---

I have my doubts about your story

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by experienced punter

I have my doubts about your story

---

I don't have a story

I have come across this review of Ana and find it very suspicious.
The reviewer Vaani2 joined on the 9 march 09 and last visited on the same day he posted his review.
My problem is the last time he logged on to this site was at 12.11pm and left a review for a girl he met at 7pm. so he left a review for a girl he was going to meet later that day... maybe its just my suspicious mind but if you look closer at the reviews, there are a lot more dodgy ones than you might think.

Adriana has a couple from the same guy, the only girl he has reviewd. look for your self and draw your own conclusions.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Epsilon

I have come across this review of Ana and find it very suspicious.
The reviewer Vaani2 joined on the 9 march 09 and last visited on the same day he posted his review.
My problem is the last time he logged on to this site was at 12.11pm and left a review for a girl he met at 7pm. so he left a review for a girl he was going to meet later that day... maybe its just my suspicious mind but if you look closer at the reviews, there are a lot more dodgy ones than you might think.

Adriana has a couple from the same guy, the only girl he has reviewd. look for your self and draw your own conclusions.

---

Well spotted Epsilon..........

Kind of related but.......

Something has always bugged me about the time here.....

Your last post was at 06:42 pm
It should either read 6:42 pm
or............................18:42......

Sorry it just bugs me.......:o

Something has always bugged me about the time here.....

Your last post was at 06:42 pm
It should either read 6:42 pm
or............................18:42......

Sorry it just bugs me.......:o[/quote]

Tell somebody who cares......;):D
put your sugestion in the E-I suggestion box....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by irishcolm

theres no link between these girls, they're just loads of reviews from loads of seperate punts...... i do have luck now and again on the horses and we all have our own methods of finding a buzz..nothing suspect or unusual about that....

---

LMFAO. I know I've heard that one about winning all the money on the nags before........oh yes, now I remember, that's the story that the boys from the CAB are usually told by guys who's sources of wealth are being investigated.

Given that Colm was complaining about the prices that escorts are charging, and then was even trying to flog his own ass, he must have won one hell of an amount on the geegees to finance this level of punting over the course of a number of months. Or maybe it was all courtesy of the National Lottery. :D:D:D

This shit just gets funnier and funnier......this guy has real talent.