View Full Version : I propose Milfhunter for trusted reviewer
adogwithabone
17-03-10, 22:22
We need to expand the number of trusted reviewers and I believe that we, ourselves, are the best judges. For a start I propose Milfhunter. He has 28 reviews and over 500 posts. Is there anyone who believes his reviews are not genuine????????????????????????? Is there any serious reason why he should not be awarded trusted reviewer status.
I think that we should aim to have all reviewers with 10 unchallenged reviews or 5 reviews and 20 substantial posts as trusted reviewers. So I think that we should start working our way down the list.
i def think that he should get trusted status. His reviews are usually bang on and fair.
While I have no problem with Milfhunter I think it would be way too soon for him to recieve a badge, I'm not accusing him of anything nor am I implying anything but I'm on the bench when it comes to someone posting 500+ posts and 28 reviews in a few days over 4 months recieving a badge!!
TiffanyTees
17-03-10, 23:19
We need to expand the number of trusted reviewers and I believe that we, ourselves, are the best judges. For a start I propose Milfhunter. He has 28 reviews and over 500 posts. Is there anyone who believes his reviews are not genuine????????????????????????? Is there any serious reason why he should not be awarded trusted reviewer status.
I think that we should aim to have all reviewers with 10 unchallenged reviews or 5 reviews and 20 substantial posts as trusted reviewers. So I think that we should start working our way down the list.
here here thumbs up for milf hunter HE is a GENUINE REVIEWER and definitely a man
Tiff xx
here here thumbs up for milf hunter HE is a GENUINE REVIEWER and definitely a man
Tiff xx
This is the type of imput we need in order to grant someone thrusted reviewer status but it shouldn't be automatic just because it has been shown he is genuine by a respected escort!
Unfortunately we have another badge bearer that was given the thumbs up by a few escorts yet he was shown to be lets say, forgetful as to the ladies he actually seen so he just reviewed them anyway.
People seem to get mixed up between a client being genuine and a clients reviews being thrustworthy, yes Milfhunter is genuine but i think we should let time tell if his reviews are thrustworthy!!
adogwithabone
18-03-10, 01:20
This is the type of imput we need in order to grant someone thrusted reviewer status but it shouldn't be automatic just because it has been shown he is genuine by a respected escort!
Unfortunately we have another badge bearer that was given the thumbs up by a few escorts yet he was shown to be lets say, forgetful as to the ladies he actually seen so he just reviewed them anyway.
People seem to get mixed up between a client being genuine and a clients reviews being thrustworthy, yes Milfhunter is genuine but i think we should let time tell if his reviews are thrustworthy!!
We are talking about such a flawed system here that the idea that everyone has to be whiter than white is a bit ott. What we need is just reviewers that we can reasonably trust to warn us of the fakes and advise us of the good escorts, most of the time. everyone makes mistakes, nobody is perfect. The important thing is that genuine reviewers will acknowledge mistakes and rectify them
I've never really been convinced that badges are a good idea. I have my own list of who I trust, and MILF Hunter is one of the reviewers I trust, badged or not.
I do think we need to clarify what badges are supposed to mean, and how people get them or lose them.
adogwithabone
18-03-10, 09:09
I've never really been convinced that badges are a good idea. I have my own list of who I trust, and MILF Hunter is one of the reviewers I trust, badged or not.
I do think we need to clarify what badges are supposed to mean, and how people get them or lose them.
For me the trusted reviewer system is important in building a body of reviews/reviewers that can reasonably be relied on when there are so many fake reviewers, some with high numbers of reviews. We all look at a persons reviews, particularly in respect of those escorts that we know personally and we decide whether the reviewer is reliable or not. Rather than trying to make our own individual assessment based on one or two escorts in common, we can make a better informed, collective decision on the basis that most escorts will be common to one or other of us.
For instance, A.N. Other may have ten reviews of girls that I have not met and I am considering visiting one. The review of the escort by A.N. Other is the only review of the girl. Other than a guess, how do I know if the reviewer is genuine or a pimp?? I would know because the rest of you, my peers, who have shared escorts with him would have passed his reviews and awarded him trusted reviewer status. It is simply a way that we can help each other. No system is perfect, we will get it wrong sometimes and fakes will slip through but it is the best way that we have to sort out the good from the bad.
In the same way that I have proposed someone to be a trusted reviewer, anyone should be able to propose that the status be taken away from someone.
I would like to transfer the power over these kind of issues to ourselves, both escorts and clients and have them decided by vote after a debate where anyone can air their views.
oneeyedreilly
18-03-10, 10:00
For me the trusted reviewer system is important in building a body of reviews/reviewers that can reasonably be relied on when there are so many fake reviewers, some with high numbers of reviews. We all look at a persons reviews, particularly in respect of those escorts that we know personally and we decide whether the reviewer is reliable or not. Rather than trying to make our own individual assessment based on one or two escorts in common, we can make a better informed, collective decision on the basis that most escorts will be common to one or other of us.
For instance, A.N. Other may have ten reviews of girls that I have not met and I am considering visiting one. The review of the escort by A.N. Other is the only review of the girl. Other than a guess, how do I know if the reviewer is genuine or a pimp?? I would know because the rest of you, my peers, who have shared escorts with him would have passed his reviews and awarded him trusted reviewer status. It is simply a way that we can help each other. No system is perfect, we will get it wrong sometimes and fakes will slip through but it is the best way that we have to sort out the good from the bad.
In the same way that I have proposed someone to be a trusted reviewer, anyone should be able to propose that the status be taken away from someone.
I would like to transfer the power over these kind of issues to ourselves, both escorts and clients and have them decided by vote after a debate where anyone can air their views.
A lot of sense in what you say, it would really help everybody if we could try and establish a greater number of reviewers who can be trusted. Half the reviews you read would definitely seem bogus and there are a number of reviewers with many reviews that are definitely dodgy.
adogwithabone
18-03-10, 10:23
While I have no problem with Milfhunter I think it would be way too soon for him to recieve a badge, I'm not accusing him of anything nor am I implying anything but I'm on the bench when it comes to someone posting 500+ posts and 28 reviews in a few days over 4 months recieving a badge!!
The trusted reviewer badge is not much use if it is only handed out to a handful of oldtimers. We need to reach out and identify all those reviewers that we can reasonably trust. We also need to encourage reviewers to make more reviews and more objective reviews.
If you want to keep it so precious then lets have a hierarchy of one, two or three badges. I do not like the idea myself but if it allows us to embrace a wider group of genuine reviewers, then so be it.
MILF Hunter
18-03-10, 18:48
Many thanks :)
Dirty Harry
18-03-10, 18:54
i see no reason why milf hunter shouldn't get a trusted reviewer badge:)
thehighwayman
19-03-10, 10:01
I have nothing against Milf Hunter but just speaking in general it would be open to abuse if someone could get a trusted badge for just been a member for a few months with a number of posts and reviews. I agree with Anon it should be longer term members who become trusted reviewers.
If it was so easy to become a trusted reviewer what's to stop a banned user coming back fastracking his badge by posting alot and having 10 or more reviews in a short space of time.
adogwithabone
19-03-10, 17:33
I have nothing against Milf Hunter but just speaking in general it would be open to abuse if someone could get a trusted badge for just been a member for a few months with a number of posts and reviews. I agree with Anon it should be longer term members who become trusted reviewers.
If it was so easy to become a trusted reviewer what's to stop a banned user coming back fastracking his badge by posting alot and having 10 or more reviews in a short space of time.
Once the reviews are genuine, it is no matter to me whose toes he trod on to get banned. Has anybody stopped looking at NBT's reviews because bcause he was banned. Let us not get a trusted reviewer badge confused with a long service medal or a good behaviour gong.
I have nothing against Milf Hunter but just speaking in general it would be open to abuse if someone could get a trusted badge for just been a member for a few months with a number of posts and reviews. I agree with Anon it should be longer term members who become trusted reviewers.
If it was so easy to become a trusted reviewer what's to stop a banned user coming back fastracking his badge by posting alot and having 10 or more reviews in a short space of time.
Well at least we would know why the badges are/were awarded. Some of the current holders got them because they were a friend of someone and one that I asked does not even know why he was given his.
thehighwayman
19-03-10, 19:07
I don't know what criteria was used for the trusted reviews up to now as it was nbt that gave them out.
When I said banned users I didn't mean only nbt and co but also banned users who have targetted escorts with malicious threads,pms, reviews.
Just drop it in the E-I post box................:D:D:D
20910
I don't know what criteria was used for the trusted reviews up to now as it was nbt that gave them out.
When I said banned users I didn't mean only nbt and co but also banned users who have targetted escorts with malicious threads,pms, reviews.
So what is the current criteria?
adogwithabone
19-03-10, 20:00
I don't know what criteria was used for the trusted reviews up to now as it was nbt that gave them out.
When I said banned users I didn't mean only nbt and co but also banned users who have targetted escorts with malicious threads,pms, reviews.
What I am trying to do in this thread, besides promoting Milfhunter, is to devise a system of awarding and regulating trusted viewer badges as a way of helping all of us try to identify the more dependable reviews.
The basic premise behind what I am proposing is that reviews are for the benefit of escorts and clients and, therefore, the trusted viewer status should be awarded, or taken back by their vote, not decided by someone in E-I.
I agree the original system for choosing who got a badge was based on NBT personal criteria which I couldn't comment on as I would only be guessing, but I do know he studied there reviews, took there board activity on board and even contacted escorts to verify reviews submitted and if he was happy with all above you got a badge. He didn't go by volume either as mini-me (anonymouse) has a badge and he only submitted 4 reviews. Personally I would be in favour of starting afresh and going forward with clear guidelines as to how you qualify for one and also how you can apply as you can't expect the mods to keep track of every member so you would only be considered when you apply!!
I agree the original system for choosing who got a badge was based on NBT personal criteria which I couldn't comment on as I would only be guessing, but I do know he studied there reviews, took there board activity on board and even contacted escorts to verify reviews submitted and if he was happy with all above you got a badge. He didn't go by volume either as mini-me (anonymouse) has a badge and he only submitted 4 reviews. Personally I would be in favour of starting afresh and going forward with clear guidelines as to how you qualify for one and also how you can apply as you can't expect the mods to keep track of every member so you would only be considered when you apply!!
Yes
Scrap it and start again
adogwithabone
19-03-10, 20:23
I agree the original system for choosing who got a badge was based on NBT personal criteria which I couldn't comment on as I would only be guessing, but I do know he studied there reviews, took there board activity on board and even contacted escorts to verify reviews submitted and if he was happy with all above you got a badge. He didn't go by volume either as mini-me (anonymouse) has a badge and he only submitted 4 reviews. Personally I would be in favour of starting afresh and going forward with clear guidelines as to how you qualify for one and also how you can apply as you can't expect the mods to keep track of every member so you would only be considered when you apply!!
In oder to start we have to agree on basic criteria which would make one elegible. We also have to agree on who decides whether the award is given or not. Whatever we decide, we have to convince E-I to go along with it.
WhenLoveComesToTown
19-03-10, 20:34
You should have put a poll with this post adogwithabone
I find Milfhunter very reliable and I already consider him one of my trusted reviewers badge or no badge.
I would like to see him get his badge though just to make it official.
In oder to start we have to agree on basic criteria which would make one elegible. We also have to agree on who decides whether the award is given or not. Whatever we decide, we have to convince E-I to go along with it.
Personally I feel that normal board members should be able to input into the decsion but ultimately it would be up to a panel to make the final decision which would include if not solely consist of the mods, after all they are board members like you and me. At least we can be sure they are not trolls or a returning trouble makers with alterior motives..
You should have put a poll with this post adogwithabone
I find Milfhunter very reliable and I already consider him one of my trusted reviewers badge or no badge.
I would like to see him get his badge though just to make it official.
I agree with this totally. Milf is one of the few reviewers I trust, not only are his reviews genuine but, they are informative without being coarse. He gets my vote defo. As regards other comments that somone only here 4 months etc. should not have a badge...this is a community, the members comments should count, forget time, number of reviews etc. If both girls and punters say it's a genuine situation that's good enough for me without the usual crap from on high. I do not agree with the badge system but I do believe if we have such a system, and escorts and punters alike recognise a genuine situation where it should be rewarded, then I think this is a perfect case....
adogwithabone
19-03-10, 20:59
You should have put a poll with this post adogwithabone
I find Milfhunter very reliable and I already consider him one of my trusted reviewers badge or no badge.
I would like to see him get his badge though just to make it official.
It is my intention to have a poll but first, I wanted to generate a debate on the issue. Milfhunter is a test case. I do not think that anyone has expressed any doubts about his reviews, therefore, he is a trusted reviewer and should be designated as such for the benefit of clients using the review system. I was hoping to agree on criteria and a proposal/scrutiny/voting system which would be recognised by E-I, thereby allowing the members to decide. Milfhunter is easy but I would like to include a lot more like yourself and people with even less posts /reviews.
without the usual crap from on high
I'm just a lowly board member voicing my opinion :o, I really do hope i don't come across as preaching, just saying it as I see it!!
Dirty Harry
19-03-10, 21:02
You should have put a poll with this post adogwithabone
I find Milfhunter very reliable and I already consider him one of my trusted reviewers badge or no badge.
I would like to see him get his badge though just to make it official.i am sure he will get a trusted reviewer badge if and when the time is right ..i agree that a trusted reviewer badge helps lads to make the right choice when they book an escort most of the time but not always i sometime in the past booked escorts that had no reviews at all and had the best service ever this was long before i became a mamber here of course..
The irony of all this is the fact that quite a few of us are married men classed as "Trusted Reviewers" whilst cheating on the wife and family, friends etc., big time. I do remember that I made quite a fuss of getting my trusted reviewer badge, alas the novelty has worn off now and I'm really not that bothered, having said that, I wish all those awarded their TR medals all the best and may they clock up hundreds of reviews and enjoy all those beautiful women in this land of make believe. (Here's the medal I should be getting.
https://www.escort-ireland.com/boards/attachment.php?attachmentid=20911&d=1269032476
Whatever we decide, we have to convince E-I to go along with it.
The tail wagging the dog..........:D:D:D
On a serious note, the problem with polls is people may vote against a person for personel reasons, this is in the case of an open pole, in the case of a closed poll where nobody knows who voted for who, it's open to corruption........
I'm sure E-I will take on board any suggestions people make for trusted reviewer badges, and opinions they may have as to those people..........
But at the end of the day guys, all the people who are posting on this thread will make up their own minds as to who they do and do not trust, regardless of badges.........
The tail wagging the dog..........:D:D:D
On a serious note, the problem with polls is people may vote against a person for personel reasons, this is in the case of an open pole, in the case of a closed poll where nobody knows who voted for who, it's open to corruption........
I'm sure E-I will take on board any suggestions people make for trusted reviewer badges, and opinions they may have as to those people..........
But at the end of the day guys, all the people who are posting on this thread will make up their own minds as to who they do and do not trust, regardless of badges.........
Exactly...considering the lack of criteria for awarding them.....why have them....
adogwithabone
19-03-10, 22:01
Exactly...considering the lack of criteria for awarding them.....why have them....
Because it would be a big help to me and, I think a lot of others. You guys may be able to instantly recognise those reviewers that you can trust but I lack that clairvoyance. I look at an escort that I like the look of and she has, say four reviews, all positive, two are once off but two have 10/20 reviews each. I will look at these guys and their reviews but the chances are that we may not have escorts in common. Do I believe them or not???? If they were trusted reviewers where others had already checked them out and voted them in, I would accept their reviews without question. If I got a bad steer, I would be back here looking for their status to be removed. This is simply a way for us to help each other by identifying the reviewers that we can reasonably rely on.
I want to make it clear that I do not want to bestow honour on anyone. I just want to make it a little bit easier to find a good shag quickly.
I see what you are saying...but I still go by the same criteria for reviewers I trust...it is not instant. I look at the reviews..I read...check out the girl and if I like, I'll look at the guys other reviews, check out the other girls he has visited. If I visit this girl I'll know how accurate the review was and whether I value his opinion. I also value PM the guy, escort and the chat facility here. After all that it is remembering which reviewers you have followed and who you trust. The current badge does not help...you have to do the research. I agree with the voting in system for a future change, it should be punters and escorts though I think.
Eldorado911
20-03-10, 16:45
I do trust MILFHunter and he should get his medal.
I just think he can shorten a little his reviews. Clean, towels, clean apartment, clean mouth could be summarised in just CLEAN.
MILF Hunter
20-03-10, 20:00
I do trust MILFHunter and he should get his medal.
I just think he can shorten a little his reviews. Clean, towels, clean apartment, clean mouth could be summarised in just CLEAN.
duly noted
cheers El :)
adogwithabone
20-03-10, 21:18
Now that NBT has gone is there any way for anyone to become a 'trusted reviewer'???? Has anyone else been entrusted with the power to bestow the badge???????????????????????? Everyone seems to be in agreement that Milfhunter is a trusted reviewer but how do we make it happen???? Do we have to send a petition to Patricia??